The biggest story of training camp has been the battle for the back-up quarterback position. Tom Brady has not seen the field all preseason and chances are he won’t see the field Thursday night at Giants Stadium, as he is nursing a foot injury, but, this has allowed the three key back-ups to battle it out for a roster spot and the job as primary clipboard holder. Here, after three game, is a summary on all three quarterbacks, and my prediction on who stays and who goes.
The first player I will look at is Matt Cassel. Cassel is going into his fourth season, but he hasn’t started a football game that mattered since high school, as at USC he was a back-up to both Carson Palmer and Matt Leinart. Cassel was the primary back-up last season, and this pre-season he has been the #1 quarterback with the Brady injury. His stats have been very pedestrian, 15/28, no touchdowns. 1 interception, but the stat that stands out, 4.8 yards per pass attempt. This includes one game with Wes Welker and two games with Randy Moss, and while the offensive line has been less than stellar, Cassel at times looks like a statue under fire and seem unable to find his check downs, and even when he does get the ball off, he hasn’t been accurate down the field, throwing more passes at defenders than offensive players. And on top of that, the teams has not scored an offensive touchdown with Cassel under center. Using almost the same parts of one of the greatest offense in history, Cassel has neutered them better than almost any defense could.
The second player I am going to look at is Matt Gutierrez. Gutierrez has played in two games, he missed the Tampa game after missing a couple of practices the during the week, and in two games he is 24/36 with two touchdowns and one interception. He leads the team in yards per attempt with a very nice 8.1 yards. Gutierrez showed some very good poise vs. the Eagles this past weekend and his two touchdown strikes were the only points put up by the offense that night. Gutierrez also showed some very good pocket presence and the ability to hit his check downs, as he hit Ventrone and Evans multiple times to avoid taking negative plays and to move the chains and keep drives alive.
And finally, the third player of this triad is rookie third round pick Kevin O’Connell. O’Connell has worse stats than Cassel, with 12/28, no touchdowns as well, along with two interceptions and 4.2 yards per attempt in two games, as O’Connell didn’t play vs. Philadelphia. While O’Connell’s numbers are worse than Cassel’s, keep in mind that O’Connell is a rookie, in his first camp, seeing his first game action, while Cassel is in his fourth year with more time spent in the system. O’Connell has shown some good mobility in getting out of the pocket and has potential to make plays with his legs if needed.
So now after reviewing the games and looking at the stats, I think that the Matt Cassel experiment will be coming to an end next week. Matt Gutierrez has out played Cassel and O’Connell and deserves a shot as the primary back up behind Tom Brady. O’Connell is very raw, and being a third round pick I think gets O’Connell a shot as the quarterback, learning the offense behind Brady and Gutierrez and maybe overtaking Gutierrez next season after a year on the team, learning the offense and the pro game.